Garypilot

I am wavering between two GCS,need some help to choose one!

Recommended Posts

I am considering buying a new GCS,  so I finally got to come to these two GCSs. I think I can get some advice from here to choose the final one.

The first one looks very ruggedized with stabilized tray. The second one looks so portable with chic appearance and it is from a brand I know not so well. Their GCS look so different from traditional ones but it takes risk trying too edgy products, right ?  Tell me what you think, thanks!
 


 

UAV FACTORY.PNG

拼接图.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I personally use a Toughbook to run my flight control software. It rugged, self-contained, sealed against the weather and fairly reasonable in price. Choosing a GCS based upon looks alone is really short-sighted. Without any specs for your above choices, no-one can offer an informed opinion that means anything.

Edited by R Martin

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 8/16/2019 at 8:58 PM, R Martin said:

I personally use a Toughbook to run my flight control software. It rugged, self-contained, sealed against the weather and fairly reasonable in price. Choosing a GCS based upon looks alone is really short-sighted. Without any specs for your above choices, no-one can offer an informed opinion that means anything.

NO.1 

UAV Factory’s off-the-shelf portable Ground Control Station (GCS) . It is described as a flexible and universal solution for controlling unmanned vehicles andpayloads. By using modular electronics compartment (MEC), application specific hardware can be quickly installed. The GCS can be configured to control unmanned aircraft vehicles (UAV), ground robots, bomb disposal robots, remotely operated vehicles (ROV) and other robotic devices. 

Key Features

 Universal off-the-shelf ground control station
 Based on fully ruggedized Panasonic CF-31 Toughbook
 Integrated Toughbook docking station
 User dedicated modular electronics compartment with threaded mounting base
 Two, 50 W stabilized 12 V power outputs for electronics compartment
 A comprehensive set of connections: 2 serial (RS-232), 5 USB, 2 Ethernet, 1 video in, 1 VGA in (optional), 1 Microphone in, 1 Audio out,
PCMCIA slot, HDMI
 Super bright 17” and 13” touch screen displays
 10-32 VDC input range
 Hot-swappable dual lithium batteries
 Intuitive power monitoring display (battery status, input voltage, internal temperature, power consumption)
 Over-voltage, over-current, reverse polarity, battery over-discharge protection
 User-serviceable fuses
 Removable Cordura bag for accessories
 Carry handles, wheels and shoulder strap for convenient transportation
 Ruggedized and lightweight design

NO.2

This is Etlas NEO II from MMC UAV. It features high integration, military-grade IP 54 ingress protection, and it combines all the functions of image transmission system, data transmission system, handheld remote, image display system, and industrial laptop.

Key Features

 Combining all functions of image transmission system, data transmission system, handheld remote, image display system, and industrial laptop

 Equipped with Photon A10 transmission system that integrates high resolution image link with data control station for bidirectional transmission

 Adopts dual LCD screens with the upper one showing images and the lower one showing ground station system interface, with 1500 nit brightness screen

 It is resistant to water, dust and shock and able to work perfectly under difficult working environment such as dust or rainstorm

 4-hour battery life satisfies long-time operation

 It measures only 406*306*93mm and weighs only 8kg, which makes it quite portable and convenient for emergent outdoor flying operations

 It has an 8-kilometer transmission distance and can satisfy most needs for remote control and image display.

 It has multiple data connector ports which are adaptable with multi-rotor drones, fixed-wing drones, robots, industrial controller and monitoring gimbal, etc. 

Specifications

Size(L*W*H) 406*306*93mm
Weight 8kg
Material Aluminum Alloy Plastic
Computer Intel Core i5, 8GB Storage,128GB SSD
Screen Upper screen:15.6-inch LCD /Resolution 1920*1080
Lower screen: 12.1-inch LCD /1500 nit 
Battery 4S Lithium Battery
Video Output HDMI
Transmission Distance 8km
Working Temperature -20℃~60℃
Storage Temperature -30℃~70℃

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Personally I would go with the Toughbook. I was using an Apple device and it doesn't do well at all in the heat without and lot of babying. Another consideration is weight. I don't know how you operate but we have to pack stuff into remote and limited access sites occasionally and carrying a lot of equipment through the brush is a real pain. Finally, will it work with the aircraft you fly? Can you link it on the job site easily or is the process cumbersome. Last point: power consumption. I know everything has a battery that will work forever under adverse conditions....I've got a few of those too. The fact of the matter is heat and cold change all that and are you going to need a power source to run your stuff when the battery fails in 100°+ heat after two hours?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
18 hours ago, R Martin said:

Personally I would go with the Toughbook. I was using an Apple device and it doesn't do well at all in the heat without and lot of babying. Another consideration is weight. I don't know how you operate but we have to pack stuff into remote and limited access sites occasionally and carrying a lot of equipment through the brush is a real pain. Finally, will it work with the aircraft you fly? Can you link it on the job site easily or is the process cumbersome. Last point: power consumption. I know everything has a battery that will work forever under adverse conditions....I've got a few of those too. The fact of the matter is heat and cold change all that and are you going to need a power source to run your stuff when the battery fails in 100°+ heat after two hours?

The MMC GCS in the second picture group claims to be compatible with pix4 and other open source flight control. So I guess this won;t be a problem. But you do remind me of the battery for the GCS which can be heavy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Garypilot said:

The MMC GCS in the second picture group claims to be compatible with pix4 and other open source flight control. So I guess this won;t be a problem. But you do remind me of the battery for the GCS which can be heavy.

To get around that and solve other problems, I added a portable generator. Powers the GCS, the battery charger, the fans, lights if needed, ect... of course that is another 50# I have to cart around.....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.